Categories See All →
- Articles on Hinduism
- Meditation and Yoga
- Hindu Scriptures
- Mystical Experiences
- Saints and Gurus
- MP3 Bhajans (Audio)
- Videos on Hinduism
- Gods and Goddesses
- Temples and Holy Places
- Vedic Architecture (Vastu)
- Vedic Astrology (Jyotish)
- Science and Nature
- Hinduism in the News
- Art and Culture
- Hindu Festivals
- Travel in India
- Ayurveda and Health
Paths are many, the Rishi’s call it by many names
Published on Nov 10 2013 07:13 AM | Posted by Yogi Baba Prem | Articles on Hinduism
There is now a term to describe what Hindu’s are doing. Hindus are frequent to embrace what Sri Dharma Pravartaka coined as “radical universalism”, or the belief that all religions and teachings are essentially the same. This same view is also apparent within the teachings of Vedacharya Vamadeva Shastri (David Frawley). In modern sociology this is commonly referred to as “Eclecticism”, referring to piecing together a belief system based on fragments of different religions.
While practitioners of the new-age movement really have no basis to support this view aside from opinion, the Hindu will likely look to the Vedas to support such a statement; and the most commonly quoted verse from the Vedas is from the Rig Veda 1.164.46:
ekam sad viprãh bahudhã vadanti, agnim yamam mãtarišvãnam ãhuh.
This verse is commonly misquoted as:
“Truth is one, paths are many.”
“Truth is one, the Rishi’s know it by many names.”
This translation ignores several important words and the entire rest of the verse.
The entire verse roughly translates as:
The seers called one by many names as they speak of Agni, Yama and Matarishvan.
There is considerable difference between the two verses. The problem is that only a small portion of the sloka is quoted, namely—the seers called one by many names-- ekam sad viprãh bahudhã vadanti. But, as stated earlier, the remainder of the mantra is completely ignored. The context of the suktam is ignored as well. Upon examination, one will see that the mantra is not intended as justification that all religions are the same, but rather is talking about Vaidika, Bharata Varsha, Sanatana Dharma or what later become known as Hinduism.
Examining the entire suktam, one quickly discovers that the first 42 stanzas are devoted to the Vishvadevas commonly translated as all-gods, but in reality is a special grouping of deities together within a rik. Other deities mentioned in this suktam are Vak, Surya, Kala which is a hidden reference to Kali, and Sarasvati; as well as Mitra, Varuna and others. It becomes clear that the subject is not regarding the similarity of religions, but rather that the Supreme Vedic deity is known by many names. This supreme deity is identified within the Upanishads as Brahman, as Brahman is the “one” that the rik is referring to. In other words, all the Vedic deities are one with Brahman.
This is not to say that world religions do not share some common ground, as certainly there are universal values such as love, compassion and other important qualities, but the fact that the world’s religions share a handful of similarities does not mean they are teaching the same thing, or that they have the same goals.
Separation of the World’s Religions
One may ask, “What separates the world’s religions?” The answer to this question first and foremost would be destination. For example, the Christian and Muslim follower have a destination of heaven. Within Hinduism this philosophy appears, but is a lower destination as this is implied when one goes to the loka of the deity. The loka is NOT the final destination within Hinduism. The final destination within Hinduism is self-realization or enlightenment. A realization of oneness with Brahman, as compared with what Hindu’s would perceive as a loka for the Christian and Muslim.
Reincarnation is a key and important distinction between Hinduism and many of the world’s major religions. Hinduism has always embraced the concept of reincarnation. Often critics argue that reincarnation does not appear within the Vedas; but the term ‘samsara’ appears frequently within the Upanishads., with the earliest references associated the Brihadaranyaka. Likewise, we see in the Rig Veda:
Om AA ta etu mana punah kratve dakshaaya jiivase,
Jyok ca suuryam drishe. Rig Veda 10.4.57.4
“May your spirit return again, to perform pure acts for exercising strength, and to live long to see the sun.” Rig Veda 10.4.57.4
Clearly this is a reference to reincarnation, though the word reincarnation does not literally appear, rather the spirit or intention of the mantra is such.
Several of the world’s religions teach salvation, as opposed to Hinduism’s liberation. Karma is another important distinction between Hinduism and many of the world’s other religions. Occasionally there are attempts to say that karma is like the Christian “Golden Rule”, which is the ‘treat others as you would like to be treated.’ But in reality karma is a divine law that recognizes the need for realization, learning and resolution of conflict within the field of the mind. Hinduism embraces Atma-jnana or knowledge of the self. Hinduism has the most extensive teachings on meditation and the art of meditation and mantra.
What does the rest of the Suktam say?
While it is accepted, at times, to quote only one rik from the Vedas for a point or teaching, as we have seen, this is not the case in 1.164.46 where only a portion of a line is used to make a point. This is generally not accepted within the Vedic lineages or teachings. It is also important to consider the deities associated with the suktam as well as the subject matter of the entire suktam for clarity on a sloka.
The entire suktam (1.164) continues onward to discuss the astral body and even the solar calendar referring to the “twelve-spooked wheel” which is a reference to the solar year. There are references to seven horses which are “yoked” to the one wheeled car; this is a reference to 7 known planets in the Vedic astrological system which are connected or “yoked” with the Sun which is the one wheeled car. It was understood by the Vedic rishi’s that many of the Gods could be called “Sun Gods” as they are born of Aditya, which is a reference to the Vedic zodiac. These riks connect the Vedic deities with the Vedic zodiac and their relationship with Aditya. But there is more to this suktam than just astrological information.
The appearance of seven is significant within this suktam, as it does reference the chakra system. The seven Vedic Rishi’s are commonly referred to as the saptarishis and are equated with the stars of the big dipper. Additionally the saptarishis are associated with the seven chakras. When examining the chakra connection, these Rishi’s are given a dualistic quality except for the seventh which has transcended duality (the crown chakra located at the top of the head). This teaching is found within this suktam, as verse 15 states that “…the seventh is single born, but the six are twins…” indicating the masculine and feminine qualities of each chakra.
But this suktam has much more to teach. The Vedic worlds are identified, as the suktam says “the heavens are my parent…the navel is my relative…the spacious earth is my mother. There are deep mystical teachings in this suktam and it is very long, but of all the various subjects and secret teachings contained within it—radical universalism or the idea that all religions are basically one is not one of them.
Ancient View of Other Religions
While it is most likely that Hinduism or Sanatana Dharma has influenced the world’s religions to a greater degree than is currently accepted by scholarly circles, what was the ancient view towards other religions? The Vedas does shed some light on these issues, but it addresses these issues within Sanatana Dharma to the greatest degree; recognizing two groups of people: Dharmic and Adharmic, those that are for and practice dharma and those that are against dharma (adharma). This is also addressed in the Vedas as battles between the Devas and the Asuras, and is also illustrated in conflicts between the the Angirasa’s and the Bhrigus. And finally as battles between the Vedic people’s that embraced dharma and those that had allowed dharma to slip to lower levels such as with the Panis and Dashyus during the Vedic age. So the Vedic traditional view would examine other religions to see if they were truly practicing dharma and not automatically agree that they are all basically saying the same thing. The Vedic teachings would say to stand against adharma if you are a follower of dharma.
Author's Name: Yogi Baba Prem
Author's Website: http://www.vedicpath.com
Latest Files from Downloads Section
A critical study of the work "Vaimanika Shastra" (PDF)
Today, 02:39 PM A critical study of the work “Vaimanika Shastra” released by scientists from the Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, in 1974. First, the historical aspects and authenticity of the work are discussed. Subsequently, the work is critically reviewed in respect of its technical content. They concl...
15 Khadgamalas Recited in Sanskrit (MP3)
Nov 04 2013 06:04 PM 15 Khadgamalas Recited in Sanskrit in MP3 format. Sanskrit stotra for Devi.
15 Khadgamalas in Sanskrit with English Transliteration
Nov 04 2013 05:03 PM 15 Khadgamalas in Sanskrit with English Transliteration in PDF format.
Mookambike Devi Mookambike Ringtone
Nov 03 2013 04:45 PM Ringtone of bhajan "Mookambike Devi Mookambike" for mobile phones. Mookambika Devi is a deity of Goddess Parvathi located in Kollur, Karnataka. The legend says that a local demon Kaumasura was living in the area and kept the population of surrounding areas in terror. It was predic...
Gayatri Mantra Ringtone
Nov 03 2013 02:17 PM Ringtone of the Gayatri Mantra for mobile phones.om bhur bhuvah svah tat savitur varenyam bhargo devasya dhimahi dhiyo yo nah prachodayat. The Gayatri Mantra is a highly revered mantra, based on a Vedic Sanskrit verse from a hymn of the Rigveda (3.62.10), attributed to the rishi (sage...
Latest Topics in Discussion Forums
stabilityVedic Astrology (Jyotisha) Today, 02:35 PM
When will i get stability in my career and income? Date of birth 25-6-1968 Birth time: 9.02 pm Birth place:Gajapatinagaram.andhra pradedh.
Full topic ›
Full topic ›
Multiple Issues in lifeVedic Astrology (Jyotisha) Yesterday, 06:08 PM
Respected All, Currently I am facing multiple issues in life. I am in Saturn Mahadasha since 1999 and have been facing several ups and downs in life. Have done struggles in studies, career, health and marriage. I got married at the age of 30; but immediately after 6 months have to get s...
Full topic ›
Full topic ›
Delay in marriageVedic Astrology (Jyotisha) Yesterday, 04:33 PM
My date of birth 04-03-1982 at 4.00pm at Chennai.now I am running 31 years.my marriage is getting delayed. My aged parents r worrying for the delay . Kindly inform me whether my marriage will happen and if so when. My parents are very anxious To know ur expert predictions.
Full topic ›
Full topic ›
Please help to find career path through astrologyVedic Astrology (Jyotisha) Yesterday, 05:07 AM
I request all the astrologers to please help me to find my carrer path. How and when would I be able to start earning money and have some stability in terms of work.? I am still unmarried and directionless..Please shed some light on my career or help me to fnd an accomplished astrol...
Full topic ›
Full topic ›
Gods own stones - ShaligramaRecommended Websites 08 Nov 2013
The website has lot of useful information about the hindu holy stones called Shaligrama. http://www.shaligrama.wordpress.com
Full topic ›
Full topic ›
knowledge is important but what is more important is how we utilise the inknoledge received. its a fact that our great philosophy oor religion is always misguided by christians and islamist each being the final path to salvation. the christians say the only path is jesus, the muslims mohammad. our grat vedic knowledge accepts humanity as one with different paths of attaining that inner realization. the western world today is freely accepting this view as it is easy to imbibe with no forced dogmas. our great vedic teachings explicitly recognises that there is great beauty in difference and we as a human race need to recognise this great beauty of understanding the perpetuate the human chain. excellent article.
This is an interesting article, and I'll add my 2 cents. I agree with Mahatma Gandhi when he said that all religions lead to the same end, just as a single tree has many branches and leaves. I know dozens of Christians, both Catholic and Protestant, who are open-minded people and who feel a deep respect for other religious traditions. My personal interpretation of Dharma and Adharma is that to be Adharmic would mean to be disrespectful of a spiritual path, no matter which one it is. If all paths lead to the same source, disrespecting one is to disrespect all.